App Runner vs ECS vs Elastic Beanstalk
For a new containerised web app or API, use Amazon ECS Express Mode: AWS has closed App Runner to new customers and points them there. Existing App Runner users can keep running and plan a move at their own pace. Choose Elastic Beanstalk when you deploy source code on a managed platform (Java, .NET, Node.js, Python and others) or need Windows, and plain ECS when you need full control of the service.
The three options compared
| Factor | ECS (incl. Express Mode) | Elastic Beanstalk |
|---|---|---|
| Input | Container image | Source bundle on a managed platform, or a container |
| What it creates | Express Mode: Fargate service, ALB with HTTPS, scaling, networking, logs | Standard mode: EC2 instances, load balancer, Auto Scaling; Cluster mode: runs on Amazon EKS |
| Service charge | None; you pay for Fargate, the ALB and other resources | None; you pay for the resources it creates |
| Escape hatch | Every resource is in your account and editable | Resources are in your account; changes outside Beanstalk can drift |
| Windows | Yes, on ECS (Fargate Windows has a 5-minute billing minimum) | Yes, in Standard mode |
| Status | Actively developed; the AWS-recommended successor to App Runner | Actively developed (Standard and Cluster modes) |
App Runner itself remains available to existing customers, including creating new services, but AWS says it does not plan new features. Its billing model was per-container-instance memory while provisioned, plus compute while actively serving requests.
When to choose ECS Express Mode or ECS
- You have a container image and want an HTTPS URL with scaling, without designing the load balancer, target groups and security groups yourself. Express Mode needs an image, a task execution role and an infrastructure role.
- You are migrating from App Runner. AWS documents a blue/green move using weighted DNS so both run side by side while traffic shifts.
- You expect to outgrow defaults. Because Express Mode builds an ordinary ECS service, you can later change networking, deployment strategy or capacity without re-platforming.
- Several small services share a VPC: Express Mode services with the same networking configuration share an Application Load Balancer, which reduces cost.
When to choose Elastic Beanstalk
- Your team deploys application code rather than images, and wants AWS to own the runtime platform (language version, web server, OS patches through managed updates).
- You run traditional .NET on Windows Server or an app that expects a VM, with worker environments fed by SQS.
- You already run on Beanstalk and it works. There is no service charge, so moving only for fashion buys nothing.
Beanstalk now has a Cluster mode that runs applications on Amazon EKS, aimed at faster deployments and better packing of many environments. Standard mode runs directly on EC2.
Migration notes
From App Runner: recreate the service in ECS Express Mode with the same image, attach the custom domain with an ACM certificate, then shift Route 53 weights gradually and delete App Runner once traffic is at zero. Recheck VPC connectors, environment variables and secrets references, because these are configured differently on ECS.
From Beanstalk to ECS: containerise the app first (Beanstalk Docker platforms help), then move the load balancer and DNS. Keep the database outside the Beanstalk environment, or decoupling becomes the hardest part.
Common wrong reasons
- "App Runner is simplest, so start there." New accounts cannot. Express Mode gives a similar first experience on a service that keeps getting features.
- "Beanstalk is legacy." It is still developed and suits platform-managed source deployments; the question is whether you want images or source bundles.
- "Plain ECS is too much work." Express Mode removes most of the initial setup while leaving the full ECS model underneath.
Questions
Is AWS App Runner being discontinued?
App Runner is closed to new customers. Existing customers can keep using it, including creating new services, and AWS continues security and availability work but plans no new features.
What does AWS recommend instead of App Runner?
Amazon ECS Express Mode. It creates a Fargate-based ECS service with an Application Load Balancer, HTTPS, scaling and networking from a container image, with no extra charge beyond those resources.
Does Elastic Beanstalk cost extra?
No. You pay only for the EC2 instances, load balancers, storage and other resources the environment creates.
A simple platform is only simple until a deploy fails at night; then you want the service events and the last log lines quickly. CloudConsole is being built to show alarms, logs and recent changes on a phone with production guardrails.
About the app → · Download on the App Store